10 Best Wedding Tuxedo Rentals on Long Island
Groom and groomsmen looking great in their rental tuxedos. © Dan Wagner 2023
The best Long Island wedding tuxedo rental places offer a large tux selection, excellent alterations, and friendly service at a reasonable price. You can go to one of the major players in the wedding tuxedo rental business, or to a smaller tuxedo rental place such as a local mom and pop shop. Personally, as long as they had what I wanted, I’d probably use the smaller tuxedo rental place.
That’s because I like going someplace where they know my name. And in America, we love rooting for the underdog. And if the smaller tuxedo rental place costs a little bit more—so what? You’ve already spent a small fortune on your Long Island wedding, what’s a few dollars more? Unless it impacts what you have left for your wedding photographer!
This 10 Best Wedding Tuxedo Rentals on Long Island list will help you spend your wedding tux rental budget wisely. As with anything desirable in life, brides and grooms owe it to themselves to compare the pros and cons of wedding tuxedos, photographers, and other important wedding vendors. So, to maximize the usefulness of my Long Island Wedding Blog, I’ve decided to create a series of blog articles designed to make your vendor comparison searches easier, faster, and more informative. Being somewhat of a shopaholic myself, I’m an expert at separating the wheat from the chaff—in other words this blog can help you avoid the worst fate known to mankind—buyer’s remorse!
This list features wedding tuxedo rentals close to Huntington, NY, because most of the Long Island weddings I photograph are within an hour drive from my Huntington office. I figure it’s easier to work with wedding vendors closest to where you’re getting married and having your reception. Please feel free to let me know if I haven’t included your favorite wedding tux rental place, so I can add them to this list. By the way, please don’t judge the Long Island wedding tuxedo rental places shown below by this webpage—view their website links, and contact them to learn more. Also, the photos next to the wedding tuxedo renter’s info are screenshots from the tuxedo renter’s website and/or Instagram. Thank you!
Use the wedding tuxedo renter’s email addresses for information and pricing requests!
Note: Any best list is subjective. Just because I haven’t included a Long Island wedding tuxedo rental place on this list, doesn’t mean they’re not one of the best. A few of the wedding tuxedo renters on this 10 best list provide contact forms instead of an email address. If you decide to use them, make sure you get their email address so you have an easier way to reach them on the days leading up to your wedding, and on the day of your wedding.
Boy ring bearers swinging from a tree in their rented tuxedos. © Dan Wagner 2023
10 Best Long Island Wedding Tuxedo Rentals
Men’s Warehouse Tuxedo Rentals in Huntington, Plainview, and Westfield Southshore Mall
Find a Men’s Warehouse near you and make an appointment.
Plainview, 413 S Oyster Bay Rd 415, Plainview, NY 11803, 516-681-8120
Westfield Southshore Mall, 1701 Sunrise Hwy, Bayshore, NY 11706, 631-206-1323
Worth Noting: When it comes to renting a tux, the Men’s Warehouse has it down to a science. They offer in-store and online fit evaluation, and shop from home rentals.
Sounds good! Does this mean I should stop looking at wedding tuxedo rentals places on Long Island and simply go to my local Men’s Warehouse? Great question! If it were me, I would find the styles I liked on their website, next I would make a list of the tuxedo sizes needed with their online fit evaluator, and finally I would call them to make sure they had what I wanted.
“Family-owned and operated. Proudly serving Long Island for over thirty-seven years! Voted the #1 Men's Formalwear store since 2010”
What Do I Need to Know Before Choosing a Long Island Tuxedo Rental?
Great Question! From my point of view, it’s not just about whether a wedding tuxedo rental place has the style and size tuxedo you’re interested in, but what the quality and experience of renting from them will be like.
Wedding tuxedo rental reviews are extremely important! When reading reviews for a Long Island tuxedo rental place I look for repeating patterns such as bogus reasons why a tuxedo rental wasn’t ready on time, and other issues such as bad fittings.
Are their tuxedo rentals in good condition? Or do they look worn and tired? Do their tuxedos have any shiny areas?
Does the tuxedo rental place you’re considering have good rental terms? Will you have enough time to return the tuxedos. Do they offer damage insurance?
Is your wedding tuxedo rental place friendly, knowledgeable, and easy to deal with? How long will you have to wait for alterations?
Does the tuxedo rental place have tuxedos for your boy ring bearers? Having one tuxedo rental place that offers adult and children tuxedo rentals makes it easier than working with multiple vendors.
“Our mission is to provide you with professional, knowledgeable service, and the attention you deserve. We look forward to meeting with you to discuss arrangements for your special day. Ask us about our Bridal, Prom,and Quinceanera packages. We offer a large selection of designer tuxedos including Ike Behar, Perry Ellis, Ralph Lauren, Michael Kors and many more.”
“Since the first Karako store opened in 1982 in the Lower East Side of Manhattan, we've been dedicated to making a difference in the lives of our customers. Our business is the result of the Karako Family's visionary leadership, along with generations of associates focused on helping customers and communities save money and live better. This rich heritage defines who we are and what we do today.”
Long Island Wedding Tuxedo Rental FAQs
What happens if I damage my wedding tuxedo rental? In many cases, depending on your rental agreement, easy-to-repair damages are included. However, tuxedo damages that can’t be repaired will incur replacement fees.
What happens if I fail to return the rental tuxedo, or any of the included rental items? Naturally, the renter would be required to pay replacement fees.
How much will I be charged for returning the rental tuxedo late? This too depends upon your rental agreement. Generally the late fees run about $20 per day.
When is it okay to wear a white dinner jacket? Generally it’s from Memorial Day through Labor Day.
When can I wear a tailcoat? Tailcoats, or 'tails,' are are only worn for evening events. They generally require a white pique shirt, a white pique vest and a matching bow tie. Invitations that call for tailcoats may read 'Black Tie No Option' or 'White Tie.'
What is a cutaway? A cutaway is a black or gray coat without satin lapels—also known as a 'morning coat' because it should not be worn after sundown. The gray coat is worn with gray striped slacks, and is the traditional attire for morning weddings. The black coat goes with black tuxedo slacks and is acceptable for any part of the day.
What is a black tie wedding? A black tie wedding invitation is a more forceful request than 'Black Tie Optional.' It means you should wear formal attire such as a tuxedo and accessories.
Should the groom and groomsmen wear matching tuxedos? That’s up to you. Personally, I think they should. However, it’s fun for the groom and groomsmen to show their individuality by wearing a unique vest, tie, pocket square, jewelry, and / or socks.
Are cummerbunds and vests important? Currently, they’re very popular. The nice thing about cummerbunds and vests is that they help maintain the well-dressed look when the jacket is removed. Cummerbunds and vests will help make your wedding dancing photos extra special!
“Off Main Apparel was founded in 2019 by a local Long Island family who has hopes of becoming a highly recognized Men’s Lifestyle & Luxury Store. Our OMA family has over 20 years of experience in both the wedding and fashion industry. We’re highly committed to customer satisfaction and go out of our way to make sure you’re happy.”
“Many stores dabble in formal wear. Tuxedos are a sideline to them. Not at S & S Tuxedos. We have lived and breathed formal wear since 1949. That means you get a lifetime of knowledge and experience to serve you. Our knowledgeable sales staff and tailors can assist you in every way, from a perfect fit to proper wedding attire. S & S Tuxedos has a tremendous inventory of over 10,000 tuxedos and accessories in stock. We are an A+ member of the Better Business Bureau.
At S & S Tuxedos we offer quality. Some brand names we carry are Oscar de la Renta, After Six, Perry Ellis, Ralph Lauren, Lord West, Tallia, Calvin Klein, Joseph Abboud and many more. We carry Super 120 wool tuxedos to rent or purchase. "The finest material on the rental market”
How Much Will My Wedding Tuxedo Rental Cost?
According to Men’s Warehouse, tuxedo rental costs range from $99 to over $200 depending upon the tuxedo package and style. Like the saying goes, “You get what you pay for, and you pay for what you get.”
In addition to renting wedding tuxedos, your groomsmen may also require dress shoes, cufflinks, and vests.
How Can I Save Money on My Long Island Wedding Tuxedo Rental Cost?
Order as early as possible to save money on rush fees.
See if your tuxedo rental place offers group discounts.
Consider renting suits instead of tuxedos. This is a good option for less formal weddings. And for beach weddings, anything goes!
If you frequently attend formal events, or have a lot friends who want you to be a groomsman at their wedding, then you might be able to save can save a lot of money by simply buying a tuxedo, dress shoes, and cufflinks. Unfortunately, this approach will only work if the groomsmen at the wedding are wearing a similar style tuxedo. If you’re lucky, you might only need to rend a vest and bow tie to match the other groomsmen.
While not on Long Island, The Suit Spot is a short drive from Nassau County, Long Island. “Our wedding stylists have outfitted thousands of wedding parties and are here to help your groomsmen look their best, and will walk you through the complete process. Fathers or the groom or bride can be added as well—even if they’re getting a different look than the groomsmen. You can have different looks for the groom, groomsmen & fathers and still qualify for our special deals!”
“Foresto Tuxedo was founded in 1940 by Michael Foresto, a young master tailor from Italy with an entrepreneurial vision. Today, under the ownership of his son, Dominick, Foresto Tuxedo has earned a reputation for exceptional customer service. Our professional staff expertly fit each gentleman that visits our Mineola showroom. We take pride in making your special occasion memorable. Each rental garment and accessory is professionally dry cleaned and prepared for you.”
What Should I Look for and Do When Renting a Wedding Tuxedo?
Do they have a good website? Why? Because wedding tuxedo rental places and other wedding vendors shouldn’t have a disorganized website—that’s just good common sense. Tuxedo rental websites with online fit evaluation are especially useful.
Make sure to button the jacket of your tuxedo after alterations. You want to make sure it’s comfortable.
Wear the same tee shirt you plan on wearing at the wedding. Also wear a pair of shoes with the same heel height so your pant legs will be the correct length.
It’s a good idea to bring the bride and a good friend with you when you look at wedding rental tuxedos. This way, you can make sure the bride is happy, and also have someone to take photos so you can see how you look.
Mayfair S/C—194 Jericho Tpke Ste 30, Commack, NY 11725—631-543-3295
Charles Schwab Building—600 Old Country Rr Rm 1SW, Garden City, NY 11530—516-222-2030
GET SIZED
Answer a few questions and our fit algorithm will recommend the best sizes for you. Rest assured, our in-house fit specialists review every order for accuracy.
TRY IT ON AT HOME
Try the fit before you commit. We’ll send you the suit of your choice so you can strut your stuff in front of the mirror for 48 hours—totally free.
VISIT A SHOWROOM
If in-person is more your style, book an appointment at one of our showrooms to preview our garments and nail down your sizes.
Simple Tips for Long Island Wedding Tuxedo Photography
As a Long Island wedding photographer, I was told by my mentor, the late great Bart Stevens, that I should always ask the men to put the hand closest to camera in their pants pocket. This is accomplished by placing the hand under the jacket.
When buttoning a single breasted jacket, you should only button the middle button.
Attaching a boutonniere is best accomplished with the jacket off. It’s funny how many people struggle to attach their boutonniere while wearing their jacket.
This tip is for wedding photographers. In Photoshop, selecting a plus 1, 2, or 3 in the shadow adjustment setting will help bring out the details in a black tuxedo. Similar adjustments can be made during Raw file processing. Sometimes you’ll want to do a feather selection to avoid changing the shadows in other areas of the photo.
Stay tuned for more Long Island wedding photography blog articles!
“Dan Wagner was the best money spent on our wedding. He was nice, professional and did a great job. He took great candid photos—which I love. Not only did we get every picture he took, but the photos were full size and without any writing on them, and they arrived just a few days after we came back home from our honeymoon. We got to choose many pictures for our album. Because everything was digital, he e-mailed me exactly what the layout of the album would be before it was printed, and I was able to make changes. Our album was the nicest I have seen, and everyone who has seen it wishes they had hired him.”
—Genevieve and William
Every Bride and Groom Deserve Beautiful Wedding Photos!
Please feel free to share your thoughts and experiences about the best Long Island tuxedo rental places in the comment box below. Have a wonderful wedding, and many thanks for visiting my Long Island wedding photographer blog!